Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

In February 2023, following a 6 year research and learning time, General Synod voted on a draft package of prayers and readings to be used for blessing a same-sex relationship. Included in the pack was examples of how these could be used to provide a stand-alone service, including exchanging rings or lighting candles. The prayers and services were voluntary – like remarrying divorced people the vicar could say no if it went against his conscience.

Between February and July the Bishops were tasked with 3 jobs – refining the Prayers of Love and Faith; writing new Pastoral Guidance on sex and relationships and writing legal guidance.

The old pastoral guidance entitled Issues in Human Sexuality was written over 30 years ago, and was never finished and referred to ‘homophiles’ – a word not in common usage. The guidance declared in its introduction that it was not the last word on the subject. Sadly, it became used unofficially in the discernment process for new priests – who were asked to agree to its findings and so many called people were rejected from ministry because they were gay.

The Legal Guidance was to protect clergy and churches from being sued if their conscience prevented them from performing the services, or if being sued if they did perform the services.

The draft Prayers of Love and Faith (and draft service structures) can be found in this document from page 21. https://www.churchofengland.org/sites/default/files/2023-01/gs-2289-living-in-love-and-faith.pdf

By July none of the 3 documents were ready. Also, a small number of the more conservative evangelical churches had threatened to withhold their parish share if the bishops implemented what had been agreed at Synod.

The November paperwork for Synod showed that the Bishops had succumbed to this pressure and the stand-alone services were removed from the documents and the Legal Protection and Pastoral Guidance still had not been done. The only thing on offer was a prayer being said during intercessions during a normally scheduled meeting. 

No one was happy.

An idea to put in an amendment calling for the return of the stand-alone services was suggested. Previously, the Bishops all vote on bloc – so even if we put in the amendment the thought was that they would have all taken the party line and voted against it. Steven Croft, the Bishop of Oxford, put in what became known as ‘The Oxford Amendment’ calling for the House to consider whether some standalone services for same-sex couples could be made available for use, possibly on a trial basis, on the timescale envisaged by the motion passed by the Synod in February 2023

So Back to Synod in November for yet another 9 hour debate on whether LGBT people should be treated as equal human beings.  Before walking into Church House Bishop Sarah and I were called Apostates by some protesters outside.  We all had to walk through metal detectors to check we weren’t planning on stabbing or shooting each other.  In the chamber we were screamed at for being children of satan which led to a brief suspension of synod to remove the protesters. 

So at the last minute – The Bishop of Oxford put in the amendment and both Archbishops and Bishop Sarah supported it.

An amendment to provide separate episcopal oversite – effectively splitting the church into two camps failed.  The ‘not paying your parish share’ idea was roundly criticised as stealing from fellow Christians – someone pointed out that by not paying, their vicar’s stipend was being paid for by the inclusive churches.

The biggest problem we still had was that without the legal reassurance anyone performing or not performing the services could be sued. And the conservative evangelicals had made these observation of legal pressures.

Several people pointed out that these services had actually been happening, unoffically, under the radar, for the last 30 years – and no one had been sued yet.  Without the amendment – these would have become illegal so we would have ended up in a worse place than where we started.

The amendment passed, despite not having the legal reassurances people desperately needed and the pastoral guidance that was promised. 

So we wait, again, maybe a month for the full suite of prayers and services to be commended for ‘experimental’ use.  At the same time they will start the process of going through the ‘B2’ route to become official liturgy of the same value as the standard wedding service – this process will take 2 years and require consultations with all the diocesan synods.

See the Church Times Article: Exhaustion, hurt — and resignation after Synod same-sex debate